Breaking the Silence of 1,500 Deaths Each Day

By Tim Butcher

FIFTEEN HUNDRED people die in the Congo each day as a result of conflict but the world’s attention remains focused elsewhere. Why?

First, there are those who dispute that figure. Outsiders who have never been to the Democratic Republic of Congo (the current name for a country known previously as Zaire, the Belgian Congo and the Congo Free State) question its accuracy. There has not been a single day in post-Saddam Iraq or Taliban-infested Afghanistan when 1,500 souls have perished and, skeptics argue, how could any conflict be worse those.

Having crossed the vast chaotic country astride the Equator – from one side to the other is the distance from London to Moscow - I have to say the toll of 1,500-a-day published by the Lancet, Britain’s leading medical journal, is horribly plausible. They might not all die in combat but they die nonetheless, mostly through avoidable diseases in a failed state so anarchic public health outside large cities has totally collapsed.

In the north of Katanga province I entered the country’s killing fields, walking through savannah scrub where human bones lay so thick on the ground they had not been buried. Later in my trip when I was making my way by pirogue – a hollowed-out tree trunk canoe – down the Congo River, I met a nursing mother whose baby was dying from dehydration, a condition that can be reversed with the simplest of medical care, re-hydration salt solutions. Her eyes were dull with fatalism as she explained the infant was not the first she had lost to disease. And even in supposedly developed cities like Kisangani, the former colonial centre of Stanleyville and model for Conrad’s Inner Station, I was implored by a Congolese river guide to take his 4-year-old son with me. The guide said I would be ``rescuing’’ his son from the Congo.

Second, the world seems reluctant to grasp the heartache of the Congo because the turmoil is so complicated. The violence in the Congo does not lend itself to tidy categorization; it is not `genocide’, although there are occasionally genocidal components; it is not a `crime against humanity’, although some of the systemic sexual violence against women falls into that category; it is not part of the `War on Terror’, although close attention should be paid to the Congo’s poorly-policed uranium mines in Katanga, mines that produced the uranium refined for the bomb used at Hiroshima, and the proximity in nearby east Africa of al-Qa’eda sympathizers.

But policy makers should not be shy of complexity. The multi-layered and multi-faceted nature of turmoil in the Congo can still be brought back to basic principles such as installing and invigorating the rule of law. The country’s government has made one important decision by calling for the International Criminal Court to help bring perpetrators of chaos in the east of the country to justice. This is an important surrender of an African nation’s sovereignty, basically an admission that `We, the Congolese government, need outside help with justice’.

Such an important concession should be vigorously supported by outsiders who could send the personnel, equipment and means to detain the suspects. At present this job falls to a poorly organized and, frankly, unsuitable force of United Nations peacekeepers. If extraordinary rendition is justified anywhere in the world then surely it is against the killers of the eastern Congo.

Third, cynics bleat it was ever thus in the Congo. They are right the country has a long association with bloody violence. The colonial experience of the Congo was one of the most brutal in Africa and the post-colonial period has been an almost perpetual continuum of rebellion, dictatorship, conflict and instability. But it does not follow outsiders should give up on a region. The outside world helped with elections in the DRC two years ago, the first meaningful poll in four decades. The result is a democratically-elected government but more has to be done to entrench the rule of law. Supporters of the main opposition leader in that democratic election clashed after the poll with government gunmen on the streets of the capital, Kinshasa, killing hundreds.

A hundred years ago this November international pressure helped the Congolese when outsiders, including US congressmen, forced the Leopold II, King of the Belgians, to cease his murderous private rule over the Congo and transfer it to the Belgian government as a colony. It was not the end of the Congo’s problems but it was a definite improvement.

It should inspire us today not to give up on a country and those 1,500 souls.

Tim Butcher’s `Blood River – A Journey To Africa’s Broken Heart’, is published October 2008 by Grove Press

Timbo Tim Butcher Middle East Correspondent The Daily Telegraph + 972 54 569 3698 Author of `Blood River - A Journey To Africa's Broken Heart' Richard & Judy Book Club 2008 Sunday Times No1 Bestseller Shortlisted for Samuel Johnson Prize 2008 British Book Awards 2008 `Read of the Year' Runner-Up Watch the film: http://www.britishbookawards.com/bba/movies/bloodriver.html

Watch the interview http://link.brightcove.com/services/link/bcpid1484342781/bctid1498976173 www.bloodriver.co.uk

Students and Community Organizers Launch Countdown to Break the Silence Congo Week

The United Nations says the conflict in the Congo is the deadliest in the world since World War Two. Since 1996, it is estimated that nearly 6 million people have died in the Congo due to conflict and conflict related causes. Throughout the past decade, Doctors Without Borders has consistently reported that the Congo conflict is one of the top ten most underreported stories in the world.

Student leaders and community organizers have responded to the silence surrounding the loss of life in the Congo by organizing throughout the globe to Break the Silence and raise awareness about the situation. They aim to mobilize young people and others in 100 countries and on 1,000 university campuses to participate in a global teach-in and week of activities from October 19 - 25, 2008.

Who: Key student leaders representing North Carolina A&T, Howard University, The University of Maryland, Bowie State, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, Friends of the Congo and other supporters.

What: Launch of countdown to Break the Silence Congo Week, October 19 - 25, 2008

When: 10 a.m. - 12 noon, Monday, September 22, 2008

Where: National Press Club
529 14th Street, NW
13th Floor, Zenger Room
Washington, DC 20045

For more information about the Press Conference, please call Friends of the Congo at 202-584-6512 or email info@friendsofthecongo.org. Visit www.friendsofthecongo.org or www.congoweek.org for more details.

Speak for the silent

By Georgianne Nienaber

If 6 million people were killed or simply vanished off the face of the Earth, you might expect an immediate international outcry, in-depth analysis of this humanitarian catastrophe. You’d expect story to be on the front page of every newspaper and magazine in the world. You’d expect broadcast and photojournalists to take every opportunity to document this story.
javascript:void(0)
Publish Post
This story has already happened in the Democratic Republic of Congo, and there has been no such outcry. This atrocity is surrounded by silence.

Responsible journalists have a duty to not only explore the reasons behind this loss of life, but to also question the “why” behind the lack of journalistic diligence and honesty in covering what is happening in the Congo today. Read more>>

UN Plane Crashes in Congo: 17 Feared Dead

KINSHASA (Reuters) - A humanitarian plane carrying 17 passengers and crew that went missing in east Democratic Republic of Congo has crashed into a mountain and there is no sign of survivors, the contracting air company said on Tuesday.

Rescuers spotted the wreckage early on Tuesday of the 19-seat Beechcraft aircraft, contracted by Air Serv International, around 15 km (nine miles) northwest of the town of Bukavu, on Congo's eastern border with Rwanda.

Read more>>

Living With Fear: A Survey of the People of Congo

The International Center for Transitional Justice, the Human Rights Center at the University of California, Berkeley and the Payson Center for International Development at Tulane University conducted a survey of 2,620 Congolese between September and December 2007. The study focused North and South Kivu, Ituri, Kinshasa, and Kisangani. The results of the survey were predictable but shocking nonetheless. A summary of the survey revealed:

• 80 percent of respondents said they had been displaced at least three times in the last 15 years
• 75 percent said their cattle or livestock had been stolen
• 66 percent said their home had been destroyed or confiscated
• 61 percent of those polled in the east said they witnessed the violent death of a family member or friend
• 60 percent said one more of their household members had disappeared
• 34 percent said they themselves had been abducted for more than a week
• 53 percent reported being forced to work or being enslaved by armed groups
• 31 percent said they had been wounded in fighting
• 35 percent said they had been tortured
• 46 percent had been threatened with death
• 23 percent had witnessed sexual violence
• 16 percent had been sexually violated and 12 percent multiple times
• 85 percent of people polled believe "those responsible for the violence should be held accountable"

In North Kivu, at the epicenter of the violence, responses to the question "who protects you" were quite revealing. Respondents answered God (44 percent), the army (25 percent), the police (8 percent), nobody (7 percent), U.N. peacekeepers (6 percent).

Click here to read complete 60 page study.

Congo Student Organizes Global Movement

At the age of 17, I was sad to leave the Congo but happy to be alive. My family and I left a few days before the second invasion of the Congo began. With only four outfits in my luggage, I thought to myself "What is going to happen to my country?"
I lived in Kinshasa 1996 when the Rwanda invasion first happened and, I could only imagine how things would get worse.

I took peace from the fact my siblings and parents made the trip with me.

The purpose of the Break the Silence Congo Week is to raise awareness about the devastating situation in the Congo and mobilize support on behalf of the people of the Congo. It will take place from Sunday October 19 to Saturday October 25. The key organizers are students from North Carolina A&T, UNC Chapel Hill, UNC Greensboro, University of Maryland, Howard University, Bowie University, and Cornell University.

Why should Americans care about the Congo? As Senator Brownback stated "Almost every American owns at least one device in which coltan has been used." American corporations have been making billions off the people of the Congo.

Read more>>

DRC Health Crisis Examined by BBC

The BBC World Service is running a series on Congo's health infrastructure. Dr. mwamba made the most salient point when he noted "If we had people who were really patriotic it would be different.", He goes on to say "But until now we have just had people scrabbling for positions to make money."

The ultimate key to good health is good governance and Congolese patriots both of which are woefully lacking in the current leadership in the Congo. A new day will come however.

Read entire article and follow the BBC Series.

Kagame Lashes Out Against ICC

Rwandan president, Paul Kagame lashes out against the International Criminal Court (ICC). His critiques of the ICC -primarily that poor nations are disproportionately targeted- are on point. However, one cannot help but point out that Kagame has deep self-interest in lashing out against the ICC. The two cases against him in both French and Spanish courts for his role in the 1994 assassination of former Rwandan president Juvenal Habyarimana, which unleashed the orgy of Hutu-Tutsi killings in Rwanda remains of concern. In addition, his two invasions of Congo in 1996 and 1998 that triggered the deaths of nearly 6 million people must be hanging over his head. Rwanda should certainly be wary, considering that the International Court of Justice has already ruled that Congo is entitled to $10 billion in reparations from Uganda because of the human rights abuses and the looting of Congo's resources during its participation in the 1996 and 1998 invasions. Rwanda is even more culpable in the Congo than Uganda but because they are not party to the International Court of Justice, no ruling can be brought against Rwanda by the Congo.

Should Kagame's US patrons decide to let him loose at some point in the future, he will be left to the devices of the levers of international justice. Nonetheless, his stance against the ICC cannot sit well with those humanitarian and policy institutions in Washington that have defended his past and current actions in the Congo, especially seeing that many of these institutions and policy analysts would love nothing more than to have the scalp of Sudan's President Omar Bashir's.

Read entire article of Kagame's outburst against the ICC.

U.S. Backs U.N. Official in Darfur Indicted in Rwanda Deaths

Rethinking the Congo: A Dedication to Daniel Boteti

By George Bakaly Sembe

After a 15 year « exile », I have been back in the DRC for exactly 16 months, given my age (29) it is not surprising that in that span of time I have learned more about my country than when I was watching it from afar. From the corruption to the lack of leadership and capacity to lead what I have seen is far more complex, I still can’t comprehend it fully, than anything you can be told in the West. We spend so much of our time discussing the symptoms of Congo’s malady that we tend to overlook its root causes. In my view it is not colonialism, or neo-colonialism the former is an historical fact that can no longer be used as an excuse almost 50 years after independence, the latter along with interventionism from different external interests is a symptom rather than a cause, the true source of our woes is the rot within our society, it is deeply rooted in our tendency to never do the right thing, our tendency to never look for the greater good, our tendency to believe that, a messiah will come down from the heaven and fix our mess for us. One of my favourite quotes from Lumumba says: “...to make you forget that you were a man they taught you their hosannas and made you believe that one day good white god will come down from the heavens and free you...” my personal experience in the DRC in the last year and a half has lead me to believe that Congolese have forgotten that they were men.

We do not believe in our own agency, a couple of years back we let the “international community” or the West, lead us to peace and through a fraught electoral process and today we believe that it will be the Chinese who will save us by building us roads and bring us “development” in all this we have accepted that the destiny of the Congolese people does not lay in the hands of Congolese. This national trait of ours translate into two things, because we hope that someone with “superpowers” will come and save us from ourselves we, collectively as a people, suffer from what can best be described as a “messiah syndrome” at one time Mobutu Sese Seko Kuku Gwendu Wa Za Banga was that messiah, then it was Etienne Tshisekedi the self proclaimed “leader maximo” after that came the turn of Mzee Laurent Desire Kabila, who was succession was bitterly contested by his son Joseph “Momemi Maki” Kabila and Jean Pierre “Mwana Mboka” Bemba with the former winning that battle by TKO. Back in Mobutu’s time his proponent claimed that everything that was good and right about Zaire as the country was known then was a credit to Mobutu, his opponent of course opined that everything was wrong about the country and the blame lay at the “Leopard’s” hands, current Minister of Infrastructure Pierre Lumbi who was minister of foreign affairs in the brief Tshisekedi I government in 1991 said “the problem of Zaire is Mobutu” well today 10 years after Mobutu died, the DRC still has problem and H.E. Pierre Lumbi hopes that the Chinese will solve it.

Today, it is the same thing the country is divided in two, Pro-Kabila who argue that the fragile peace in DRC is due, ONLY, to Kabila and anti-Kabila who blame all the ills of the country on the “Rais” and believe that Bemba and, or Ngbanda, like Tshisekedi yesterday, are the answers to all our problems, in all of this there is never an hint of inward inspection and no one takes a step toward making things better, yesterday we said “once Mobutu goes, everything will be better” today we say the same thing about Kabila, everything will just magically fix itself, no one has a plan how we just hope that we can wish that into happening.

Two events in the past week illustrate that peculiar Congolese attitude, on 30th June we celebrated our independence, I organised a football game in the town of Lemba, there was easily 700 people in attendance and though I did not utter a single word about my values or belief I automatically became known as “leader” even though I did not show any ability to do that, but these people are so desperate that they are in the search for leaders, they have lost all hope so it is easy for them to convey all their aspiration into any one who cares to accept that. Be it Mobutu, Laurent Kabila, Bemba or Joseph Kabila, we do not look at their ideas we accept them simply because they allow us to put all our burden, the burden of an entire society onto their shoulders though they could never deal with it alone.

In that Faustian bargain, the “leader” is merely asked to help his “followers” get by, he is asked to permit them to hope, he is never asked to lead, ideology is not required in exchange he is treated like a King, he becomes the archetypal African “Big Man”. Jean Pierre Bemba called his troops “my children”, Mobutu called himself “the father of the nation”, Mzee Laurent Kabila was the “liberator” and his son has brought us “peace, stability and prosperity” can you imagine any Western leader adorning such superlatives?

In my case, I realized that to my new “fans” I was the one who could bring in a job or whichever solution was needed for their problems, those people never took the time to introspect and think about what they could do for themselves, and this creates a corrupted relationship between leadership and the people whereby it is the latter that fears the former rather than the contrary, as a result the country and its meagre resources are managed in a manner characterized by a tendency to think in the short term and to exclude the masses.

The second event occurred this week end as my friend Daniel “Danou” Boteti , the Vice-President of the Kinshasa Provincial Government, was shot down by soldiers in the Ngaliema municipality. Danou four months shy of his 30th birthday leaves behind two children and a pregnant wife. What is revolting about his death is that his murderers; troops belonging to the Republican Guard, that is the President’s Praetorian guard, have been known to wreak havoc in the same neighbourhood for at least as long as I have been here, beside Danou at least 4 people I know have been attacked by these thugs in the past 6 months, the security services believe that they kill at least two people per day. Yet nothing has been done to stop them, we all try to arrange our lives in such a way that we won’t be caught outside our own neighbourhood between the hours of 10 PM and 5 AM. So the people do not demand that this situation be resolved and the authorities do not act on it, rather the presidency asks members of his cabinet to move out of the neighbourhood. Thus in an extraordinary show of incompetence the Government acknowledges its inability to secure a suburb in the capital city, we acknowledge the inadequacy and incapacity of our own agency and therefore we do nothing.

This is why we must rethink the Congo, we must engrain in our society a belief in self-help and self reliance, we must awaken from our collective slumber and ask ourselves what we can do, individually, to make our country better, Kabila’s departure like Mobutu’s will not be the answer, it is up to us all to create the conditions that can allow a just, peaceful and prosperous society to flourish and this we the people, and only we the people, can do for our country.